Comment (1) on “How And Why Classical Musicians Feel Rhythm Differently”
I think that the video makes a lot of generalizations which are not true and are rather demeaning. There are plenty of classical and orchestral musicians who not only read their butts off, but who can play incredibly rhythmically precise and with lots of feel and internalization. To be honest it is a whole lot of conjecture from someone who does not have a lot of first hand real world info. I would suppose he has never played in an orchestra. There are plenty of great players on both sides and who can play any style with ease.
I think that the video makes a lot of generalizations which are not true and are rather demeaning. There are plenty of classical and orchestral musicians who not only read their butts off, but who can play incredibly rhythmically precise and with lots of feel and internalization. To be honest it is a whole lot of conjecture from someone who does not have a lot of first hand real world info. I would suppose he has never played in an orchestra. There are plenty of great players on both sides and who can play any style with ease.